Canandaigua's Leading Coin Shop

Old & new coins, foreign and U.S., rare collector’s coins, proof sets & much more!

Cash For Your Silver & Gold!

We buy silver & gold as well as jewelry. Stop in for an honest & professional appraisal.

Magic the Gathering Cards

We buy, sell & trade Magic boosters, bundles and decks – stop in for tournaments too!

Collectible Currency

We stock a wide variety of rare US paper money!


Do you have a coin or currency collection gathering dust that might be worth something? Take it to Smitty’s to find out!

Smitty’s fully appraises and explains the real value of your coins and gold. Unlike the many “we buy your gold shops” that have popped up, Smitty’s has over thirty years of experience.

Stop in to buy, sell or trade your coins, currency, bullion gold or silver! We also buy scrap gold and jewelry.


Smitty’s is the place in Canandaigua for the Magic or Warhammer player!

We buy, sell and trade Magic cards and a wide variety of MTG Boosters, Bundles, and Decks. We also carry a huge amount of Warhammer 40k tabletop game supplies and Yu-Gi-Oh! cards.

Come join us for Magic Tournaments every Friday Night at 6PM, and tournaments every other Saturday. Call us for details.

Contact Us

Smitty’s Coins & Cards
80 South Main St.
Canandaigua, NY 14424

Store Hours

Mon-Wed-Fri: 10am-4pm
Sat: 10am-5pm
Sun-Tues-Thurs: By appointment
 Find us